Chairman Cummings’ Opening Statement at Hearing with Michael Cohen

Feb 27, 2019
Press Release

Washington, DC (Feb. 27, 2019)—Below is Chairman Elijah E. Cummings’ opening statement for today’s full Committee hearing with Michael Cohen, former attorney to President Donald Trump.    

Today, the Committee will hear the testimony of Michael Cohen, President Donald Trump’s longtime personal attorney and one of his closest and most trusted advisors over the last decade.

On August 21, Mr. Cohen appeared in federal court and admitted to arranging secret payoffs of hundreds of thousands of dollars on the eve of the election to silence women alleging affairs with Donald Trump.  Mr. Cohen admitted to violating campaign finance laws and other laws.  He admitted to committing these felonies “in coordination with, and at the direction of” President Trump.  And he admitted, he admitted, to lying about his actions to protect the President.

Some will certainly ask, if Mr. Cohen was lying then, why should we believe him now?  This is a legitimate question.  As a trial lawyer for many years, I’ve faced this situation over and over again.  And I asked the same question.  Here is how I view our role.  Every one of us in this room has a duty to serve as an independent check on the Executive Branch. Ladies and gentlemen, we are in search of the truth.  The President has made many statements of his own, and now the American people have a right to hear the other side.  They can watch Mr. Cohen’s testimony and make their own judgment. 

We received a copy of Mr. Cohen’s written statement late last night.  It includes not only personal eyewitness accounts of meetings with Donald Trump as President inside the Oval Office, but it also includes documents and other corroborating evidence for some of Mr. Cohen’s statements.

For example, Mr. Cohen has provided a copy of a check sent while President Trump was in office—with Donald Trump’s signature on it—to reimburse Mr. Cohen for the hush-money payment to Stormy Daniels.

This is new…this new evidence raises a host of troubling legal and ethical concerns about the President’s actions in the White House and before.

This check is dated August 1, 2017.  Six months later, in April of 2018, the President denied anything about it.  In April 2018, President Trump was flying on Air Force One when a reporter asked him the question:  “Did you know about the $130,000 payment to Stormy Daniels?”  The answer was:  “No.”           

A month after that, the President admitted making payments to Mr. Cohen, but claimed they were part of “a monthly retainer” for legal services.  This claim fell apart in August when federal prosecutors concluded, and I quote:  “In truth and in fact, there was no such retainer agreement.”

Today we will also hear Mr. Cohen’s account of a meeting in 2016 in Donald Trump’s office during which Roger Stone said, over a speakerphone, that he had just spoken with Julian Assange, who said there would be a “massive dump of emails that would damage Hillary Clinton’s campaign.”  According to Cohen, Mr. Trump replied, “wouldn’t that be great.”                           

The testimony that Michael Cohen will provide today—ladies and gentlemen—is deeply disturbling…disturbing.  And it should be troubling to all Americans.  We will all have to make our own evaluation of the evidence and Mr. Cohen’s credibility.  As he admits, he has repeatedly lied in the past.  I agree with Ranking Member Jordan that this is an important factor we need to weigh.  But we must weigh it, and we must hear from him.

But where I disagree fundamentally with the Ranking Member involves his efforts to prevent the American people from hearing from Mr. Cohen. 

Mr. Cohen’s testimony raises grave questions about the legality of Donald Trump’s—President Donald Trump’s—conduct and the truthfulness of statements while he was President.  We need to assess and investigate this new evidence as we uphold our constitutional, our oversight responsibilities.  And we will continue after today to gather more documents and testimony in our search for the truth.    

I had made it abundantly clear to Mr. Cohen, that if he comes here today and he does not tell him the truth…tell us the truth,  I will be the first one to refer that…those untruthful statements to DOJ.  So, when people say that he doesn’t have anything to lose, he does have a lot to lose if he lies.

And, the American people, by the way, voted for accountability in November.  They have a right to hear Mr. Cohen in public so they can make their own judgments.  Mr. Cohen’s testimony is the beginning of the process—not the end.  Ladies and gentlemen, the days of this Committee protecting the President at all costs are over—they’re over! 

Before I close, I want to comment about the scope of today’s hearing.  At the request of the House Intelligence Committee—my very good friend Adam Schiff, Congressman Adam Schiff is the Chairman—I’d intended—over the objections of the Ranking Member of our Committee—to limit the scope of today’s hearing to avoid questions about Russia.    

However, Mr. Cohen’s written testimony, in his written testimony, he’s made statements relating to Russia, and these are topics that we understand do not raise concern from the Department of Justice.  So in fairness to the Ranking Member and all Committee Members, we will not restrict questions relating to the witness’ testimony or related questions he is willing to answer. 

Finally, I remind Members that we will need to remain mindful of those areas where there are ongoing Department of Justice investigations.  Those scoping limitations have not changed. 

Finally, and to Mr. Cohen, Martin Luther King—Mr. Cohen—said the words that I leave with you today before you testify. He said “faith is taking the first step even when you can’t see the whole staircase.  There comes a time when silence becomes betrayal.  Our lives begin to end the day we become silent about things that truly matter.  In the end,  he says, “we will remember not the words of our enemies, but by the silence of our friends.” 

116th Congress